How do I help a buyer get wildfire insurance on a mountain home?

On a Colorado mountain home, wildfire insurance can make or break the deal. A buyer can love the house, have the loan approved, and still get stuck if no insurer will write a policy at a price that fits the payment. The rules shifted in 2025 and 2026. A new state law now requires insurers that use wildfire risk scores to show them to homeowners and explain how to improve them. Here's how I coach agents to handle insurance on a mountain contract, from the first showing to the objection deadline.

The short answer

Get insurance quotes the day you go under contract, not the week of your deadline. Colorado's HB25-1182 requires admitted insurers and the Colorado FAIR Plan, when they use a wildfire model or score, to give the homeowner the score, explain it, show how mitigation can change it, and allow an appeal. Documented mitigation, like defensible space, a Class A roof and ember-resistant vents, can help with the score and with discounts. If standard insurers decline, the Colorado FAIR Plan is the last-resort option, with its own rules and coverage limits.

Step by step

1. Check the risk before the offer. Look up the address on the Colorado Forest Atlas wildfire risk viewer. Walk the first five feet around the house. Ask the roof's class and age.
2. Ask the seller for the mitigation file. Invoices for tree thinning and roof work, dated photos, any county certificate or defensible space permit, and the last insurer notice.
3. Apply for insurance the day you're under contract. Brian's October 2026 blog, citing the Division of Insurance, says a new applicant gets the score and explanation within 15 days of a complete application. That window can run past a short insurance objection deadline.
4. Compare more than price. Replacement cost vs. actual cash value, the wildfire deductible, and exclusions. A licensed insurance agent explains the differences.
5. Use the contract's insurance deadline. The Colorado contract gives the buyer a property insurance objection deadline. If quotes aren't back, negotiate an extension before it passes. See Colorado contract basics.
6. Know the fallback. If several standard insurers decline, the Colorado FAIR Plan may write a policy. Check its current eligibility rules and what it pays. Ask about supplemental coverage for gaps.
7. Plan mitigation after closing. Defensible space work done after closing can support an appeal of the score and may earn a discount.

The wildfire risk score law, in plain terms

The law applies to admitted insurers and the FAIR Plan. The Division says surplus lines insurers aren't covered, so a quote from one may come with no notice or appeal right. Sources disagree on exactly when notices started, so check the current rules at the Colorado Division of Insurance.

Defensible space basics (from the Colorado State Forest Service)

• Zone 1, 0 to 5 feet: nothing that burns. Rock, gravel or pavers. No mulch, no firewood or storage under the deck.
• Zone 2, 5 to 30 feet: short grass, space between tree crowns, lower limbs pruned up.
• Zone 3, 30 to 100 feet: thinned forest. Larger on steep slopes.
• The house itself: Class A roof, fine metal mesh on vents, clearance between the ground and siding, no combustible fencing next to the house.
• Firewood and propane: well away from the house.

Embers cause most home ignitions, which is why the first five feet matter so much. Full checklists are at csfs.colostate.edu. Many counties have also adopted the Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code for new permits, which can affect re-roofs, decks and siding. Check the county building department.

Mitigation money

Colorado has a state income tax credit for qualified wildfire mitigation work paid to a contractor, for tax years 2025 through 2027, with a dollar cap and an income limit. Your own labor doesn't count. Check current rules at tax.colorado.gov and have the client talk to a tax professional. Many mountain counties and fire districts run slash drop-off, chipping or assessment programs, and some offer certificates insurers recognize. Ask the county or fire district what's available this season.

How to explain it to your client

Watch-outs

• Late quotes. The biggest risk is running out the objection deadline waiting on an insurer.
• Actual cash value vs. replacement cost. The cheaper policy may pay much less after a loss. Have a licensed agent explain.
• Surplus lines quotes. May come without the new law's notice and appeal rights.
• Undocumented mitigation. No photos, no receipts, little credit.
• Don't quote premiums or discounts. Insurers and licensed agents do that.
• STR plans. A short-term rental use can change what an insurer will write. See short-term rental rules.
• Not legal, tax or insurance advice. Send coverage questions to a licensed insurance agent.

Further reading

• Colorado wildfire risk score law: notices, appeals, discounts on kennarealestate.com
• Wildfire risk and home insurance for Colorado mountain homes on coloradomountainhomefinder.com
• Is there a Colorado tax credit for wildfire mitigation?
• Wildfire mitigation checklist for a Colorado mountain home
• How do you get and keep home insurance on a Colorado mountain home?

This is training for real estate agents. It isn't legal, tax or lending advice. Talk to an attorney or CPA. Check with your managing broker.

Frog tip: A real estate post is an ad. Put your brokerage name on it, clear and readable, every time. Learn more →

Questions

What is HB25-1182?

A Colorado law on wildfire risk models in home insurance. It requires covered insurers to share the score, explain it, show how mitigation changes it, and allow appeals.

Can a homeowner appeal the wildfire score?

Yes, with the insurer. Send dated photos and receipts for mitigation work.

What is the Colorado FAIR Plan?

A last-resort insurer for homes standard insurers decline. Check its current eligibility and what it pays.

When should my buyer get quotes?

The day the contract is signed. Don't wait for the inspection.

Is there a tax credit for mitigation?

Colorado offers a credit for qualified contractor work for 2025 through 2027, with limits. Check tax.colorado.gov and a tax pro.

Brian Lee Burke is the founder of PadLeaders, a Colorado real estate broker licensed since 2003, team leader of The Kenna Group at Keller Williams DTC (formerly Kenna Real Estate Group) and the author of Mastering Real Estate and The Real Estate Playbook. More about Brian.